Stock Regulator SEBI Prohibits Patel Wealth Advisors, Key Personnel for Market Manipulation via Order Spoofing

Stock Regulator SEBI Prohibits Patel Wealth Advisors, Key Personnel for Market Manipulation via Order Spoofing

In the bustling metropolis of New Delhi, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has taken a firm stand against Patel Wealth Advisors (PWA) and its four directors, who have been found guilty of engaging in illegal trading practices. The market watchdog has issued a ban on them dealing in the securities market and ordered the recovery of INR 3.22 crore in illicit profits.

SEBI's investigation uncovered that PWA was involved in a shady tactic known as 'order spoofing.' It's a deceitful method where large orders are placed, only to be canceled before execution, while trades are made on the opposite side to exploit the price movements triggered by these phony orders.

In its interim order, SEBI pointed out that although order spoofing had been detected earlier on a minor scale in the Indian market, this was the first time a large-scale and widespread operation of this nature had been uncovered.

Kamlesh Varshney, SEBI's whole-time member, expressed his concerns, stating that PWA's practices misled other investors and disrupted the fair operation of the market. He emphasized that perpetuating such practices would only serve to harm investors' interests and erode trust in the stock market.

"Order spoofing constitutes a manipulative, fraudulent, and unfair trade practice employed by PWA to deceive other market participants and reap profits from artificially induced price fluctuations," Varshney stated.

The probe revealed that PWA's spoofing activities occurred in both the cash and derivatives segments over a span of three years, from January 2021 to January 2025. PWA manipulated 173 stocks across 292 trading days, sometimes multiple times in a single day. In total, they executed 621 unique spoofing instances.

These manipulations involved the placement of large, phony orders far from the current market price to create a false impression of demand or supply. Once prices moved in their favor, PWA quickly executed trades on the opposite side and subsequently canceled the large phony orders, resulting in unjustified profits.

The regulator also underscored that despite numerous warnings and proceedings from the National Stock Exchange (NSE), PWA continued with these unfair trading practices. SEBI announced that it has now developed sophisticated techniques to detect such intricate manipulations in the market and will conduct a thorough investigation moving forward.

Reference: [1] SEBI

Reference: [2] The Economic Times

Reference: [3] Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA)

Reference: [4] Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC)

Reference: [5] Money Control

Insights:

• Although order spoofing may appear small-scale, its impact can be significant, leading to artificial price distortions, reduced liquidity confidence, and potential discouragement of legitimate investors due to reduced transparency.
• Global regulatory bodies are increasingly targeting cross-product manipulation, understanding that spoofing in one market can influence correlated assets elsewhere.
• The seizure of unlawful gains and market access ban imposed on PWA marks a critical turning point in India's efforts to combat insidious trading practices and protect investors' interests.

1. The fraudulent activities of Patel Wealth Advisors (PWA) in Delhi, involving order spoofing in both the cash and derivatives segments, were a large-scale and widespread operation that exploited the market, as uncovered by SEBI.
2. Order spoofing, a deceitful method employed by PWA to manipulate stock prices and reap profits, is a manipulative, fraudulent, and unfair trading practice that disrupts fair market operations and harms investors' interests, as stated by SEBI's whole-time member, Kamlesh Varshney.
3. Despite warnings from regulatory bodies such as the National Stock Exchange (NSE), Patel Wealth Advisors persisted in these fraudulent behaviors, which can impact the finance, banking-and-insurance, and business sectors, as noted by SEBI.
4. Regulatory bodies worldwide, including the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), and other market watchdogs, are becoming increasingly vigilant in targeting cross-product manipulation, such as order spoofing, to preserve the integrity of the stock market industry.

Read also: