Data Center Disputes: Shaping the Future through Arbitration in the Realm of Servers
Data centers, critical infrastructure for the digital age, are witnessing a significant surge in construction, particularly in emerging markets. This global expansion, driven by AI advancements, has the US leading the way, but most new deal activity is happening outside the country, notably in Asia-Pacific and emerging markets.
One of the key aspects of managing these large-scale projects is resolving potential disputes. International arbitration has emerged as a preferred method for resolving commercial disputes related to data center operations and management, especially for parties from different countries. This method offers efficient, fair, and confidential resolution through well-designed contractually agreed mediation and arbitration.
Recent cases exemplify this trend. In the O'Brien v. Cohere A9 case, the tribunal ordered the respondent to release escrow funds and dismissed counterclaims of "fraud" against the claimant. Similarly, the Blackboard v. IBM arbitration case resulted in IBM being awarded over USD 29 million due to improper withholding by Blackboard.
Disputes can arise between various parties involved in data center construction, such as owners, contractors, and suppliers. For instance, in the RTI & Russell Matulich v. Gateway Network Connections case, the tribunal ordered the respondents to reinstate the claimant as CEO and director and for the parties to act in good faith to rectify non-conformities in a data center project.
The increase in data center projects will likely lead to an increase in disputes, particularly around sustainability issues. As data centers require a substantial amount of energy to operate, they now consume over 4% of national electricity in the US, with a potential rise to 12% by 2028. To mitigate this, big tech firms are seeking ways to maintain their sustainability commitments, with some entering into long-term agreements to acquire nuclear power.
Investors should also protect themselves against political and regulatory changes. Safeguards include the ability to present claims against the host State to a neutral tribunal through international arbitration. Owners and developers of data centers may benefit from holding structures that make economic sense and are covered by an investment protection treaty.
White & Case, a leading global law firm, offers services in litigation, construction, international arbitration, infrastructure, transportation & logistics, and western Europe. Their international arbitration practice is recognised as preeminent in commercial, construction, and investor-State cases. However, specific names of lawyers from White & Case specialising in international arbitration and the listed fields are not publicly detailed together; you may need to consult the firm's official website or contact them directly for precise information.
Investments in large-scale data centers and renewable energy projects could lead to disputes between foreign investors and host States. For instance, disputes between data center owners and operators and host states may arise over State conduct that could threaten the viability of these investments. It is crucial for all parties to work collaboratively to ensure the success of these projects and the continued growth of the digital economy.
Demand for data centers in the US is expected to more than triple from 2024-2030, with an estimated investment cost of over $500 billion. As the data center industry continues to expand, resolving disputes efficiently and fairly will be essential to its continued growth and success.
Read also:
- Deepwater Port Construction Permits for Projects within the South Central Region's Air Regulations
- Citizen Thekla Walker, Minister, urges: "Let's face our responsibilities at home"
- Editorial Correspondence: Justifying the Elimination of a Program Earmarked for Reducing Our Own Carbon Footprint?
- Investment of $20 million in an eco-friendly ammonia production facility in Africa by SA-H2 fund
